Do
Well, Get Well, Raise Hell and Get to Heaven
Commencement
Address
Plan II Honors Program
University of Texas at Austin
May 17, 2003
|
|
|
Student
Speaker Alexandra Chirinos;
Convocation Speaker Roger Worthington, Plan II '83;
Plan II Director, Professor Paul Woodruff |
|
Roger
and Ann Worthington
with Professor Paul Woodruff |
Last time I stood in front of crowd this
big was about 20 years ago at a free concert we called Hankstock. We wanted a student body president who
wouldnt be tempted by the darker angels of the human heart. So we nominated Hank the
Hallucination, a cartoon character. Hank was the brainchild of another P2 graduate, Sam
Hurt. Sam painted Hank on my chest and back and I got to be Hank, pretending to be a
rock star: "People try to put Hank d-d-ddown, just because he cant be f-f-f-found.
Not trying to cause a big s-s-sensation, jus talkin bout my luc-c-ccination..." It
was great fun.
Hanks mortal opponent was Paul Begala. You may know Begala
today as the cheerfully liberal brawler on Crossfire. Everytime I hear Paul crab about
Bush robbing the election from Gore, I have to laugh. Begala got beaten by a 3 to 1 margin
right here, literally, by a dream candidate. And then he had the audacity to challenge the
results. Begalas crack team of politicos proved that the de facto winner was
not eligible to serve, because to serve, you had to be sworn in, which Hank
couldnt do, not being blessed with a right hand. I learned early on that politics is
a blood sport with little tolerance for vision or visionaries.
Good to be here with Liberal arts students, alumni and
faculty. As you, Im proud to be a liberal arts graduate. We have the skills to
question and evaluate, free from the tyranny of dogma. We understand that questionning and
a wide open imagination can cause discomfort to those who are content with the status quo.
We know that converting our ideals into something real isnt easy, and the road ahead
is fraught with peril, but we embrace the challenge.
At my own graduation in 1983, I listened to Walter
Cronkite deliver a very sobering prophecy about "The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse." He
warned us that War, Pollution, Overpopulation and Famine were coming at us and gathering
speed. Unless we changed our ways, he said, our Garden would soon turn to Ash.
Well, 20 years later, Im happy to report Austin
remains a small sleepy college town. Wars been abolished. The air over central Texas
has never been fresher or cleaner, and hunger is simply a state of mind.
I am not going to talk about the world going to hell in
a handbasket. If nobody listened to Walter Cronkite, the oracle of truth, Im not
sure many will listen to me. I cant even convince my 7 year old that he wont
grow up to be lean and serene on a diet of Scooby Snacks, Cheetos, and Cocoa Puffs.
Im going to talk to you this morning about
putting your Plan II degree to work so you can achieve a few of your dreams, live well and
have plenty of time left over to play. What I call the "Do well, Get well, Raise Hell
and Get to Heaven" speech.
All of you have got brains, the smarts. Youve got
the numbers, the GPA, the LSATs, the GMATs. Youve read the dead poets. Youve
studied Darwin, Einstein, Moby Dick, all the paradigm busters, legends and pioneers. Your
braincases are virtual gold minds, waiting to be harvested.
Youve got heart. You get tingly when the underdog
wins, you feel outraged at injustice. You love children and puppies. You were disgusted by
the senseless carnage at Omaha Beach and you cannot watch "Shindlers List"
twice. You may have even vowed once to cut back on eating beef after reading Upton
Sinclairs The Jungle.
Youve got intestines. But do you have the Guts?
Will you defend the principles you espouse? Are you willing to suffer a little
embarrasment, even failure? Can you change one heart and one mind, one at a time--starting
with your own?
In short, academically, youre all fairly well
rounded graduates, but will you challenge yourself to earn the privilege to call
yourself a human being? In my view, we cant take being human for granted. I
think being a human is an honor we have to earn.
I have a cartoon
picture hanging in my office. A doctor planet is delivering the bad news
to his patient, a worried looking Planet Earth. The doctor planet says: "Im
afraid you have humans." As if we were cancer.
Somethings wrong here. Humans are supposed to be
the wise and intelligent mammal, the highest and best life form. But if the Universe had a
perspective, it would probably agree that if the Earth is slouching towards
sickness its because of the unwise conduct of its most powerful stewards: we
humans.
Thats why I encourage you to undo the stereotype
of Humans as users, takers and destroyers. My Grandad was a decent and caring man. He
referred to himself as a "New World Primate." He used to carry a card around
that he would check at the end of the day to see if he had measured up as a homo sapien.
Hed ask himself, Was I:
Was I Humorous ? |
|
Did I generate laughter? (I
am reminded of Twain's adage "No army can withstand the assault of laughter",
although I'd prefer to storm the machine gun nest armedwith something more potent than a
copy of Joseph Heller's "Catch 22" or Richard Hooker's "M*A*S*H"). |
|
|
|
Was I Creative ? |
|
Did I cook up anything bizarre
but useful? |
|
|
|
Was I Romantic ? |
|
Did I adore whats
beautiful? {single out lovely wife in front row} |
|
|
|
Was I Rebellious ? |
|
Did I rage mightily against the
dimming of the light? Did I stand up to the forces of stupidity? |
|
|
|
Was I Reverent ? |
|
Did I honor the Enduring Forces
in the Universe? Did I behave in a manner that leaves the world a little better off? Even
while grateful for the advances of medicine, science and technology, did I act in a way
that respects the fact that there are limits to both what the Earth can give and
what It can take? |
Hey, like I said, its a worthy goal, to
be a human. All right. Im a practical person -- In the spirit of not letting
perfection be the enemy of good enough, its sufficient to ask: did I even get close?
Maybe 2 out of 5 for the day but knock out all 5 in, say, a week or two.
As a liberal arts graduate, youve got a
leg up on becoming a human being. Your education has given you the means to form and
express ideas, and to constantly question. Together, with brains, hearts and guts, and a
little luck, you have about all you need to succeed. 1
I know a lot of you are thinking, "yeah,
thats noble, but to get ahead and have any pull Im going to need a whole lot
of walk around money, a big house, and a respectable job." In my view, a human does
not allow the lure of wealth and splendor to undermine his or her essence. Believe me
folks, Im not saying poor is better -- Ive been both, and I prefer the means
to have. But people in search of a life well lived have learned to go for the gold (figuratively) AND give
something back.
My passion is to help people stricken with asbestos
cancer. Im a lawyer. I represent patients with malignant mesothelioma, a type of
asbestos cancer that to date has defied conventional treatments. In the litigation world,
the street says weve fulfilled our mission if we "get the money." And
thats important. However, in 15 years not a single client has ever told me hed
swap out his lungs for a million bucks, or any amount. They want more life. They want to
see their grandchildren graduate from HS. Theyre sick of being told by doctors that
mesothelioma is "incurable" so "go home and tidy up your affairs" or
"take a long cruise."
Ive spent many years in union halls, trailer
parks, and hospital rooms. I have been inside
the OR and I have seen the surgeons cut, burn and yank out the tumors
that had been squeezing the life out of my clients. I have been to their funerals. I have
won millions of dollars for widows and their families. But, contrary to popular thought,
winning the big bucks has never been very satisfying.
Yes, Ive fulfilled my contract, but what about my
larger duty as an "advocate?" An advocate is somebody "who pleads the
cause of another." And so it came to pass that taking this role seriously
required that I help find ways to give my clients more life. 2
So I reached out to the worlds top surgeons and
scientists, who typically dont work well in groups and hardly enjoy the company of
trial lawyers. I set aside my disgust and reached out to "the enemy" and found
two asbestos defense lawyers who were willing to do the right thing. Together, we formed a
charitable foundation whose mission
is to eradicate mesothelioma. My colleagues said I got in bed with the devil. But today,
weve funded six major cutting edge research grants. Weve given hope
to thousands of otherwise abandoned and desparate patients. And, for the first time
Congress is considering legislation to create a treatment program for this tragic and
preventable disease that has taken such a heavy toll on our Navy veterans. (NOTE: you will need to view
the document [.pdf] using Adobe Acrobat)
Plan II is an "interdisciplinary honors
program." I helped build a coalition between doctors, industry, victims and their
lawyers because thats what I was trained
to do. I was trained to bridge the gaps betweens disciplines. As Plan II
graduates, weve been taught to bring warring factions together, to find the common
ground, and unite against the common enemy. We know our time is best spent fixing the
underlying problem.
If you can put your training to work like that, the
Honor -- if not the Glory, and perhaps even the wealth -- will follow.
Look, its not going to be easy. The high road is
a hard road and along the way youll make mistakes. Were imperfect. Most of the
time we dont even know who or what we are. Kurt
Vonnegut said :
"We are who we Pretend to be,
So we must be Careful choosing
Who we Pretend to be."
This sounds cynical, the notion that we are simply
opportunists, without a core set of values. Yet, it seems that in the span of a single
day, I change personalities like a traffic light.
Somedays our ideals are subsumed by the seduction of
raw power. One of my favorite movies is Glengarry Glen Ross, a story about salesmen. In the opening scene
the "closer from downtown" is browbeating the staff, threatening to fire them if
they dont increase their sales volume. Ive played this intoxicating yet
shameful role. Ive played the predator, caught up in the language of the slick
Hollywood tough guy, driven by an
angry force to close the deal, feed the hole, and win at any cost. This is a mask I wear
when Im careless. Yes, its fun to win, and nobody likes the thrill of the hunt
better than I, but this sort of passion to "always be closing" is hardly
becoming of a human, let alone a Plan II graduate.
But then there are the good days. Days when you get to
wear the mask of a hero. Youve put in the hours, you know your stuff, and
youre ready to roll. You want to help. Youve got the energy to overcome
ignorance, apathy and sloth. You realize you may have to go bonkers to get your point across but hey,
thats why they call it ENTHUSIASM -- the word itself means inspired by theos or god.
I spend a lot of time dreaming about those
break-through moments. Theres an old Ute Indian saying:
When the Legends Die
The Dreams End
When the Dreams End
There is no more Greatness. 3
Why study so hard? Why suffer the risk of failure? Why
strive for Greatness? The answer has to do with the profound satisfaction of pleasing the
gods inside us, the gods who inspire us to pull off whats thought to be impossible.
I race bicycles. Heres a picture of my alter ego, Max Kash Agro, attacking from the
front on a long uphill sprint, motivated by the vision of Lance punching out his demons at
the top of LAlpe DHuez.
Look, we cant all wear the winners Jersey,
but the Jersey, or the title, or the cash, does not measure the man. I know a lot sour
"winners" and a lot of happy "losers." The difference is that one
measures himself by conventional markers, the other by his own rigorous standards.
In the movie Raging Bull, Robert DeNiros
character Jake Lamotta is beaten to a pulp by Sugar Ray Robinson. I often think about a
battered and bloodied DeNiro happily heckling Robinson after the fight: "You never knocked me down Ray."
Sometimes succeeding is simply a matter of stubbornly refusing to quit, of simply
staying upright.
You dont have to rage to deal with
adversity. One of my clients took me aside after I rallied him to declare war on his tumor -- Slash the
blood-sucking beast!, I ranted, Burn it! Posion it! Kill it!
He said:
"Roger, sometimes aggression is not the answer.
Sometimes you just need to leave er where Jesus flang it. Just let nature run its
course. In some cases [he said] doing nothing is a way of fighting back."
This brave and gentle man told me he was "living
with the truth" that he couldn't eradicate his cancer with constant pressure, and
that he was learning to "co-exist" with it. He lived with his tumor for 5 years.
The average life span for asbestos cancer is about 9 months.
Bad things do happen to good people. Sometimes
all the bravery, courage and foritude in the world wont save a good person from his
fate. We come to learn that we have a shelf life. Some of the best humans I have known
have accepted this truth. They have tried to fill their days with honor, humor and
humility. They know lifes imperfect and sometimes unfair but they dont use
that as an excuse for giving up or selling out.
In a similar way, sometimes good arguments founded on
sound principles that really can make the world a better place simply wont sell.
Its hard but we have to recognize that the best ideas dont always win. When we
get thrown for a loss, we have to dust ourselves off, set our jaw, and get back in the
game, hopefully a little bit wiser for the wear.
So plug away, exercise passion, but try not to become a
fanatic. Im sure many of you feel a burning desire to do something real big
and real important right now. Please pace yourself. Unbridled passion,
untempered by cool and calm reason, can lead to burn out or worse.
4 Plus nobody likes to be around a
zealot.
Myself, I have a clinical fascination
of those who arent cursed with naked ambition or an overworked
conscience. I sometimes dream about the merits of slacking, of "taking her easy for
all us sinners" like my favorite anti-hero, The
Dude in the Big Lebowski, reputed to be the laziest man in Los
Angeles. And Im sure one day I will learn to relax, just about the time my
snack-happy son learns to love broccoli. 5
Finally, consider this: theres no amount of
rhetoric or poetry quite as eloquent as a good example. You are the cream of the
crop. You are the best hope for humanity. Lead by example. Dont delegate the
role of being a human to somebody else. Figure out for yourself what a human should be and
then have the guts to measure up to your own ideal.
Thank you and Go Further!
---------------------------------
Footnotes:
Left on Cutting Room Floor in Interests of
Time
1. By the way, I mean no disrespect to the
late great Professor Chad Oliver, who exhorted us to acknowledge if not revel in our
animalhood. [Prior speaker, Dr. Alan Friedman, was recipient of Chad Oliver Teaching
Award]. Im not suggesting that being an animal is always vulgar. In fact, back in my
High School football days I enjoyed my role as the wedge buster on the kick -off team. It
felt gooood to abandon what little reason I had and sprint head long into the grill
of the charging Beast. But I was 17 years old, and Id like to think theres
more to life than the primal joy of shattering my opponents face-mask.
2. Since the 1940's, corporate America has
known about asbestos cancer. Since the 1960s about $56 billion has been spent on
litigation, half of which has been drained by transaction costs. I said this is nonsense.
Not a dime has been spent on a cure. Why not put trial lawyers like me out of business?
Invest in a cure.
3. I like this poem. It says that our best
experiences live on in our memories like legends. We like the way we felt when we scored
our first winning goal, or discovered our first arrowhead, or when the girl of our dreams
said "yes" when we popped the question. We want more experiences like that. We
dream of recapturing those feelings and building new or better ones. The peak memories
spur us to daydream about what its like to be our favorite singer, or playwright, or
statesman, or athlete.
4. Im reminded of that 20 year old
dreamer Chris McCandless. He read a lot of Emerson, Thoreau and Dostoyevski. He had bona
fide romantic passion. The day after his college graduation, he gave away all his money,
abandoned his car in the Mojave desert, hitched a ride up to Alaska, and walked into the
wilderness with a bag of rice and no exit strategy. He was found several months later
inside an old school bus, dead by starvation. A good kid with a good heart on his way to
becoming a human. Done in by bad judgment, bad luck and a bad berry from a plant that
turned out to be toxic.
5. Whatever mask you choose to wear, please
try not to be a phony. Youre being phony when you say or believe one thing but do
another -- chronically.
Its like exposure to asbestos fibers-- every little bit of Phonyism adds up and
accumulates like scar tissue until it dries out the soul and turns you into a corporate
tool, a hypocrite, a hollow man, all dead inside. And if you remember one thing today,
remember this: Dont ever do something despicable for pay and then plead you
were "Just Doing your Job, Just Following Orders". The Nuremberg defense was a
loser after WW II and its a loser today. You have choices, make them count, and take
responsibility. It's popular today to knock idealism -- In the movie Platoon, Sgt. Barnes, a blood thirsty
killer who called himself "Reality" mocked his counterpart, Elias, as a
"water walker." Elias was a warrior and a human. You too will face pressures to
cave in to what's expedient. But you will be remembered if not honored for your idealism,
not the times you surrendered to the herd mentality.
*** POSTED ON MAY 20, 2003 ***
|